• Newsmax has assembled a loyal audience and posted strong revenue growth but remains unprofitable.
• A pending defamation suit by Dominion Voting Systems looms large, creating the potential for a binary outcome that could sharply reprice the stock — in either direction. 
• With lofty valuation multiples and legal risks in play, investors face a choice: Buy now in hopes of a favorable legal outcome or wait for clarity and sacrifice near-term upside potential for reduced risk.

Newsmax (NMAX) isn’t attracting much attention on Wall Street, but it’s a rising force in conservative media. With a fiercely loyal audience and expanding digital ambitions, the company is playing a prominent role in right-leaning news, drawing national attention and meme-stock-level speculation since its initial public offering in March.

Yet behind the headlines, the story becomes more complex: Robust growth in revenue is offset by steep losses, and a once sky-high valuation has come back down to earth. Today, we take a closer look at Newsmax’s financial footing, legal overhangs and evolving strategy, and we try to determine whether the stock is a contrarian opportunity or simply a high-wire act without much of a safety net.

Newsmax: pivoting toward digital to reinvigorate growth

Boca Raton-based Newsmax, as emerged as a prominent force in conservative media, resonating with a politically engaged audience that often feels underserved by mainstream news outlets. Its ascent has been fueled by a consistent focus on right-leaning coverage and the rising demand for alternative media voices. It has drawn millions of viewers in the wake of the 2020 presidential election, capitalizing on a cultural and political shift toward conservative news.

Though Newsmax began with a traditional cable TV revenue model, it has expanded into affiliate fees, digital subscriptions and e-commerce. In 2024, affiliate revenue climbed to $26.7 million — a meaningful gain — but the company still relies on its shrinking cable audience amid the broader cord-cutting trend. Its digital ambitions are encouraging but still in the early stages. It also faces competition from other conservative outlets, including One America News and First TV, two privately held networks. Meanwhile, taking meaningful share from Fox News — the undisputed heavyweight in right-leaning media — remains a steep climb.

Newsmax made headlines with its late March IPO when shares soared to an eye-popping $265, fueled by retail enthusiasm and speculative momentum. But the rally was short-lived. The stock quickly reversed course and now trades around $13, a steep drop but still above its $10 IPO price. This extreme volatility highlighted the speculative nature of the company’s market debut and the uncertainty surrounding its financial trajectory. At the same time, the company continues to face challenges to its profitability and looming legal threats, including a high-profile defamation suit from Dominion Voting Systems. These cases pose serious risks to its balance sheet and complicate efforts to build a sustainable business model.

Despite these headwinds, the Newsmax has audience has grown notably, thanks its to its appeal to a conservative niche and alignment with the Trump-era Republican base. Viewership surged 50% in Q1 2024, underscoring its traction with that demographic. But with momentum now fading, the company may need to recalibrate its strategy to reignite growth in viewership.

That’s why Newsmax is betting on digital expansion. It’s scaling its Newsmax+ streaming service and diversifying its revenue streams. But with the cable TV model in decline and its digital transition still in the early stages, the company faces formidable challenges. Sustaining viewership and reaching profitability will be tough, particularly in a crowded field dominated by digital-native rivals and entrenched players like Fox News.

Strong top-line growth, but no clear path toward profitability

Newsmax’s recent financial results highlight its emergence as a growing player in conservative media. The company delivered solid top-line growth in Q1 2025, reporting $45.3 million in total revenue, an 11.6% increase year-over-year. Advertising revenue led the way, climbing 13.5% to $28.9 million, boosted by stronger Nielsen ratings and higher ad rates. Affiliate revenue also rose 12.5% to $7.4 million, bolstered by new distribution agreements and rate hikes.

Despite top-line growth, Newsmax continues to grapple with profitability, an issue compounded by elevated operating costs. In Q1 2025, the company reported a net loss of $17.2 million, a marked improvement from the $50.7 million loss a year earlier. However, adjusted EBITDA came in at -$1.2 million, a notable deterioration year-over-year, underscoring persistent cost pressures. The decline was driven by higher revenue-related expenses, increased administrative overhead and the added burden of costs tied to its transition to a publicly traded company.

One of Newsmax’s strengths is its strong cash position. As of the end of Q1 2025, the company held $127 million in cash and cash equivalents, an increase of more than 400% from the previous quarter. This healthy liquidity gives the company the flexibility to invest in growth initiatives, particularly in digital and international markets. Despite continuing losses, the company remains well-capitalized, providing a cushion against financial setbacks and market volatility.

Looking ahead, Newsmax’s ability to drive revenue will hinge on how successfully it diversifies its business model. The company is pushing into digital content through platforms like Newsmax+ and has secured distribution deals, including a multi-year agreement with Hulu + Live TV. Recent international partnerships with Supercanal in the Dominican Republic and Telecom Armenia also signal ambitions to broaden its global presence. Yet despite these moves, Newsmax relies on the shrinking cable TV market. This dependence poses a clear risk to long-term growth and demonstrates the urgency of accelerating its shift toward digital and subscription-based revenue.

Legal challenges could weigh heavily on its financial outlook. In April, a Delaware judge ruled the company aired false and defamatory statements about Dominion Voting Systems in connection with the 2020 election. A jury is now set to determine whether Newsmax acted with “actual malice” and to decide on potential damages, but the trial has been postponed to later this summer or early fall.  The risk of a material, adverse verdict or costly settlement adds financial uncertainty that could complicate the stock’s near-term trajectory.

Valuation outlook clouded by legal risks

As expected, Newsmax’s valuation tells a complicated story — balancing its rapid ascent in conservative media against the uncertainty of its long-term trajectory. While the company’s potential for growth in a niche market is clear, current valuation metrics imply lofty investor expectations that may outpace financial reality.

Trading at a price-to-sales (P/S) ratio of 4.0 — well above the sector median of 1.3 — Newsmax commands a notable premium. That valuation reflects strong growth of revenue and rising viewership, particularly in digital and streaming. But it also assumes continued momentum, which may prove difficult to sustain. Given the stock’s extreme post-IPO volatility, the current multiple could come under pressure if execution falters or digital expansion stalls.

Newsmax’s price-to-book (P/B) ratio of 12.1, well above the sector median of 2.0, reflects the market’s bullish view of its brand value and potential for growth. Investors appear to be placing a sizable premium on the company’s position in conservative media. While Newsmax does benefit from a strong brand and a loyal audience, its scalability remains a valid concern. The niche nature of its content could limit further expansion, particularly outside the US. Without broadening its appeal or a deeply diversifying its offerings, it may prove difficult to sustain such an elevated valuation.

One of the more intriguing aspects of Newsmax’s valuation is the complete lack of analyst coverage, a rarity for a publicly traded company of its size and visibility. On one hand, this could be an advantage. With no institutional price targets or quarterly estimates to anchor sentiment, the stock is driven by the enthusiasm of retail investors and news-driven momentum. It also enables the company to operate under the radar, free from the pressures of Wall Street scrutiny.

But the absence of analyst coverage also introduces risk. Without institutional oversight or valuation benchmarks, Newsmax is more exposed to market volatility and the mood swings of retail investors. This lack of guidance can amplify price swings, as seen in the sharp post-IPO fluctuations, and it may deter more risk-averse investors until the company garners broader institutional attention.

Takeaways

Newsmax presents a high-risk, high-reward profile that may appeal to investors with a strong stomach for volatility. The company’s elevated valuation — reflected in its premium P/S and P/B ratios — signals considerable enthusiasm among investors, likely because of its brand strength, loyal audience and potential for digital growth. But these multiples also imply high expectations for expansion, which may be difficult amid legal, operational and competitive headwinds.

For aggressive investors, one possible approach is to take a position now, betting the outcome of the Dominion Voting Systems lawsuit will be more favorable than the market expects. A positive legal resolution could act as a binary catalyst for the stock, removing a major overhang and potentially unlocking upside. This strategy hinges on confidence in the company’s legal footing and long-term prospects despite short-term uncertainty.

More cautious investors may prefer to wait for the outcome of the lawsuit before getting involved. While this approach may mean forfeiting any short-term rally tied to a positive court decision, it helps mitigate exposure to a potentially damaging verdict or settlement. In this scenario, the focus shifts to longer-term fundamentals, such as digital execution, profitability trends and strategic pivots, which could offer a more stable entry point once legal risks are resolved.

Andrew Prochnow, Luckbox analyst-at-large, has traded the global financial markets for more than 15 years, including 10 years as a professional options trader.

For live daily programming, market news and commentary, visit tastylive or the YouTube channels tastylive (for options traders), and #tastyliveTrending for stocks, futures, forex & macro. 

Trade with a better broker, open a tastytrade account today. tastylive Inc. and tastytrade Inc. are separate but affiliated companies.